Megaupload Video Reinstated, Universal Says “You Can’t Touch Us”
by: enigmax
A week ago today, Megaupload’s now-famous Mega Song was on its way to becoming a viral hit, only to be cut down from YouTube by a Universal Music takedown demand. Following the filing of a Megaupload lawsuit the song is back online, but Universal are standing firm. You can’t touch us on DMCA grounds, the label says in a new filing, adding it can take down any material, even if it doesn’t infringe their rights.
The up/down nature of the Mega Song video has brought the handling of copyright infringement notifications and YouTube into the spotlight. The he-said, she-said accusations have been flying for the past week, both online and in the courts.
On Wednesday, Megaupload filed for an ex parte restraining order against UMG, in an effort to restrain the label from:
(1) attempting to bar the distribution, hosting, linking, or display of the MegaUpload Video at issue in this case; (2) submitting or advancing any “takedown notices” under the Digital Millennium Copyright Act; or (3) declining any request by MegaUpload to withdraw any takedown notices with respect to the MegaUpload video.
The judge in the case, Claudia Wilken of the US District Court for Northern California, deferred judgment until today (December 16th) to allow UMG a chance to respond.
The company did that last evening and its contents are set to take this controversy to a whole new level. First, a little background.
In an attempt to reduce instances of copyright infringement, YouTube created the Content ID system (further analysis in respect of this case from Ben Jones) which gives copyright owners the opportunity to take a number of actions should their content be uploaded by other users.
Rights owners can choose to ‘monetize’ videos through adverts, restrict access to them on a regional basis, or initiate a worldwide block. In its action against Mega Song, Universal chose the latter.
But while one might naturally expect that UMG made a legitimate DMCA takedown complaint (and one that has legal implications should it be wrongfully made) Universal insists that was never necessary.
“The UMG-YouTube agreement grants UMG rights to effect the removal of user-posted videos through YouTube’s Content Management System (‘CMS’), based on a number of contractually specified criteria that are not limited to the infringements of copyrights owned or controlled by UMG,” the record label states in its filing.
What that means, in case the preceding paragraph wasn’t clear enough, is that UMG has a private outside-the-DMCA agreement with YouTube that it can take down other people’s content from YouTube even when it doesn’t infringe their copyrights.
Indeed, in UMG’s 18-page filing not once does the company give any reason or even a hint why it had Megaupload’s Mega Song taken down from YouTube. At no point does UMG claim that the video infringed its copyrights and the previous claim, that the video featured one of its artists, is completely absent.
Nevertheless, as the legal battle continues in the background, Megaupload is today celebrating a significant interim success.
“Victory,” said Megaupload founder Kim Dotcom in an email to TorrentFreak this morning. “Our video has been restored on Youtube!”
It appears that Google-owned YouTube gave UMG an ultimatum – show us you have the right to stop us displaying Mega Song or it’s going back up. UMG deliberately missed their deadline to respond (UMG say it treated YouTube’s statements as “self-effectuating”) and now the video is back online and showing 286,000+ hits.
Of course, if Universal hadn’t deliberately censored Megaupload’s content the hits would have been substantially higher and the spread even more significant. Nevertheless, for opponents of overreaching and in this instance somewhat arrogant copyright holders abusing their position for their own ends, the Mega Song takedown is a gift that will live on.
“Our legal battle with UMG is ongoing and we are going to reveal the whole truth about this censorship and the illegal take down,” adds Kim. “Lets join together against Internet dictatorship by corporations.”
So once again, courtesy of YouTube, here is the Mega Song in all its glory. Will the viral campaign regain its momentum? Embed the video and let the readers decide.
-----------------------------------------------
-----------------------------------------------
I'm putting this up also
just in case youtube turnes into the chicken shit we know them to be.
Megaupload Video Reinstated
Have a read and let us know what you think.
Jump to
- News of Today
- ↳ Front Page News
- Welcome to Robinhoods Playground
- ↳ Rules
- ↳ Welcome
- ↳ Whats needed
- ↳ Say Hello
- Destiny
- ↳ RHPG in Destiny
- ↳ Tips and Tricks
- ↳ All Good Things
- ↳ Clan member needed
- The Camp site. Our home in the Woods
- ↳ The Forest
- ↳ Rants & Raves
- ↳ Car,Bike or boat
- ↳ MMA Mixed Martial Arts
- ↳ Water Sports
- ↳ Music , If you dig the sound waves this is the Thread for you.
- ↳ The Outhouse
- ↳ The Movie House & TV Room
- Game Reviews and Game News
- ↳ Gaming News
- ↳ Video Game Reviews from Revision3
- ↳ 360 Video game review
- ↳ Wii Video game review
- ↳ PS3 Video game review
- ↳ PSP Game Review
- ↳ DS game reviews
- ↳ 360 Game Reviews
- ↳ Xbox One Game Reviews
- Online Retailers & Product Review
- ↳ 360 Product Review
- ↳ Members Reviews
- ↳ Wii Products Reviews
- ↳ DS and DSi Products Reviews
- ↳ On-line retailer Review
- ↳ Members Product Review & Retail Site Review
- Tutorials and Downloads
- ↳ Tutorials
- ↳ 360 Tutorials
- ↳ Video Tutorials
- ↳ Drive Flashing Tutorials
- ↳ Other Tutorials
- ↳ Traditional Text/pic Style
- ↳ Drive Flashing Tutorials
- ↳ Other Tutorials
- ↳ PS3 Tutorials
- ↳ WII Tutorials
- ↳ Nintendo DS
- ↳ PSP Tutorials
- ↳ Ipod Iphone & Itouch
- ↳ Programs and Downloads
- ↳ 360 programs
- ↳ PS3 programs
- ↳ PSP custom Firmware & Programs
- ↳ WII Programs
- ↳ Programs you will need for most modding
- ↳ Ipod Touch Programs
- ↳ DS programs
- ↳ Tutorials submitted by members
- ↳ Xbox360 guides go here
- ↳ PS3 guides go here
- ↳ Wii guides go here
- ↳ PSP guides go here
- Consoles
- ↳ Xbox 360
- ↳ Beginners
- ↳ General information
- ↳ 360 DVD Drive Flashing
- ↳ IPreP
- ↳ Game Backups
- ↳ Cosmetic Case Mods
- ↳ What you're playing
- ↳ Junk
- ↳ J-Tag
- ↳ Wii
- ↳ Beginners
- ↳ General information
- ↳ Soft Mod Questions
- ↳ Homebrew Apps
- ↳ Hard mod or chip Questions
- ↳ Game Backups
- ↳ What you're playing.
- ↳ Junk
- ↳ Homebrew Apps
- ↳ Playstation 3
- ↳ General information
- ↳ What you're playing
- ↳ Junk
- ↳ Blackcat usb PSGroove
- ↳ PSP
- ↳ Beginners
- ↳ General information
- ↳ Hardware add-ons or changes
- ↳ What you're playing
- ↳ Junk
- ↳ HomeBrew APP for PSP
- ↳ Nintendo DS & DSi
- ↳ General information
- ↳ What you're playing
- ↳ junk
- Phone modding
- ↳ Cell phone News
- ↳ "AnDroid os" phones
- ↳ General Information & Questions
- ↳ Guides and Tutorials
- ↳ Other Cell phones
- ↳ iphone/ipod touch
- ↳ General Discussion
- ↳ iphone specific
- ↳ ipod touch specific
- ↳ Guides/Tutorials
- Computer Gaming & Hardware
- ↳ Computers
- ↳ General information
- ↳ Hardware
- ↳ Software
- ↳ Games
- Trusted Members