stick person wrote:Well I just had another problem on a spotless disc. I hit ignore when I got the warning, checked the game when it was done and it didn't pass the stealth check. Ran AGBX and now it's passing

What you ignored was most likely the PFI or SS not being processed.
You probably had ABGX on the default level of 2, which patches/ "fixes" the stealth files.
I'm with CoFree on this one, always do your own rips. If they need to "fixed" after the rip, I wouldn't burn/play it.
I would contact the seller, try to get a replacement I guess, gl man.